Pueblo vs Crazy Horse vs Tochigi Leather: Which Journal Is Right for You?
If you’re choosing a new leather journal cover, the leather matters as much as the size or layout. Each hide has its own texture, feel, durability, and patina style — and those differences change how your journal looks and performs over years of use. At Craft & Antler Co., our leather journals handmade in Canada are crafted from premium full-grain Pueblo, Crazy Horse, and Japanese Tochigi leather, all chosen for their long-term character.
This guide compares a Pueblo leather journal to a Crazy Horse leather journal and a Tochigi leather journal so you can confidently pick the one that fits your writing habits, style, and lifestyle best.
1. Quick Comparison: Pueblo vs Crazy Horse vs Tochigi
- Pueblo leather journal: matte, velvety texture, dramatic patina, artisan feel.
- Crazy Horse leather journal: rugged pull-up look, scratch-friendly, rustic character.
- Tochigi leather journal: smooth refined veg-tan, warm sheen over time, clean classic style.
If you’re after the most visible patina and texture shift, Pueblo is usually the winner. If you want a tougher, outdoorsy vibe, Crazy Horse shines. If you want understated elegance with Japanese heritage tanning, Tochigi is your lane.
2. Pueblo Leather Journal: Texture, Patina, and Personality
Pueblo leather (from Italy) is a favourite among writers and creatives because it starts with a chalky, matte surface and develops a bold, high-contrast patina. A Pueblo leather journal feels soft and velvety in hand, with visible grain and depth that make it look artisan from day one.
Why people love Pueblo
- Matte, textured surface that feels warm and natural.
- Best leather for patina if you want fast, dramatic change.
- Colour deepens and smooths quickly through daily handling.
- Light scratches blend into the surface as patina builds.
Best for
- Writers who want a visible “story” on their cover.
- Artists, planners, and journalers who handle their cover daily.
- Anyone who loves a lived-in, heirloom look.
If your goal is a cover that evolves the most over time, Pueblo is the most rewarding choice.
3. Crazy Horse Leather Journal: Rugged, Rustic, and Built for Daily Carry
Crazy Horse leather is known for its pull-up effect — when the leather bends, the oils shift and create lighter, worn-in highlights. That makes a Crazy Horse leather journal perfect if you love rugged character and aren’t worried about marks or scuffs.
Why people love Crazy Horse
- Rustic leather journal look with instant depth.
- Pull-up movement shows use beautifully.
- Scratch-friendly — marks blend into the patina rather than looking damaged.
- Feels tough and ready for travel or everyday carry.
Best for
- Outdoor, travel, or EDC journaling.
- People who want a rugged, “gear-like” feel.
- Anyone who likes patina but prefers a more rustic style than Pueblo.
Crazy Horse patina is less “polished” than Pueblo, but more rugged and high-character. Think worn-in leather boots versus a vintage leather notebook.
4. Tochigi Leather Journal: Japanese Veg-Tan Elegance
Tochigi leather comes from Japan and is a traditional vegetable-tanned hide prized for its clean finish and refined feel. A Tochigi leather journal starts smooth with a subtle sheen, then slowly develops a warm, mellow patina that stays elegant rather than dramatic.
Why people love Tochigi
- Refined, smooth surface with a heritage veg-tan feel.
- Patina develops evenly into a soft, warm sheen.
- Clean edges and a classic look that works anywhere.
- Ideal if you want your journal to stay minimal and timeless.
Best for
- Minimalists who want a calm, polished look.
- Professional settings and work notebooks.
- Writers who prefer slow, subtle patina over fast change.
Tochigi is the quiet-luxury option in this trio — slow aging, smooth touch, and a refined silhouette.
5. Which Leather Ages the Best?
All three are full-grain, built to last, and will patina beautifully. The difference is how they patina:
- Pueblo: fastest and most dramatic patina; texture smooths and darkens quickly.
- Crazy Horse: rugged patina with pull-up highlights; scratches become character.
- Tochigi: slow, even patina with a warm sheen; stays clean and classic.
If you want the most visible transformation, Pueblo wins. If you want character marks to be part of the look, Crazy Horse is ideal. If you want slow, elegant aging, Tochigi is perfect.
6. How to Choose the Right Leather for Your Journaling Style
For everyday carry and fast patina
Choose a Pueblo leather journal. It rewards daily handling and develops the richest patina quickly.
For travel, rugged use, and a rustic vibe
Choose a Crazy Horse leather journal. It handles knocks and scratches like a champ and looks better with wear.
For clean minimalism and professional settings
Choose a Tochigi leather journal. It stays refined and ages subtly.
Whichever you choose, you’re getting a handmade leather journal cover designed to last decades and support refillable A5 or A6 inserts.
7. Handmade in Canada, Built for A5 and A6 Refills
Every cover we make is crafted in our Aurora, Ontario studio as part of our small-batch process. We cut each piece from premium full-grain leather, machine-sew for strength, and finish the edges by hand using Japanese Tokonole. Our covers are designed to fit Muji A5 and A6 inserts and most standard refills.
This is the kind of long-term full-grain leather journal craftsmanship that makes a refillable cover worth investing in — one leather piece, years of writing.
Explore our leather journal covers handmade in Canada
Final Thoughts
Choosing between Pueblo, Crazy Horse, and Tochigi comes down to the style of patina and feel you want to live with every day. Pueblo is bold and fast-aging, Crazy Horse is rugged and rustic, and Tochigi is refined and quietly timeless. All three will outlast your inserts many times over — and all three become more beautiful the more you use them.
If you want help picking a leather for your next cover, we’re always happy to guide you.
Shop A5 leather journal covers
Shop A6 leather journal covers